Comparing and Studies

When you change a design and run it again, you want to know what the change did. The Studio compares two to four analyses side by side, groups analyses into studies, and keeps notes on them.

Comparing analyses

  1. In Projects, tick the analyses to compare: the tick box on each card, or the first column of the table.

  2. Select Compare in the row above the projects. It works for two to four analyses.

The Compare page has these parts, from the top:

The projects

One card each, with its conditions and status. One of them is the reference: the others show their difference from it. It is the one marked Baseline or Best in a study they share, otherwise the first. Select Compare the others with this one on a card to change it.

Warnings

When the analyses were not made alike: different speeds or Reynolds numbers, different air, different reference values, different CGs, polars solved differently, or angles that only some of them solved. Read them first: they say how much of a difference is not the design.

What changed in the design

The changes between the designs, in plain words, for example Span +120 mm or Fin 40 mm aft. If nothing changed: The same design.

Charts

The lift curve, the drag polar, lift to drag and the pitching moment, overlaid. Against Mach is added when the Mach numbers differ.

Differences

CL max, the stall angle, best L/D, the drag at a chosen CL, minimum drag, the moment slope, the lift slope, the zero-lift angle, the trim angle and the stall speed, each with its difference. At each angle compares the angles that every analysis solved.

Flow side by side

The flow of each analysis at one angle, with one camera and one colour scale: turn one view and the others follow. Choose Surface pressure, Difference, Streamlines or Wake. Difference colours the change in surface pressure (ΔCp) against the reference; grey means there is no like-for-like point, for example on a part that moved.

At the top, Coefficients and Newtons switch between coefficients and forces. Compare in newtons when the reference values differ. Add… adds another analysis.

Noise or a real change

Every result has an uncertainty: the solver’s own scatter and the mesh’s. The Uncertainty band switch shades it on the charts. In the Differences table, a difference is called better, worse or changed only when it is larger than the two bands together; otherwise it is within noise. A difference within noise is not an improvement.

Studies

A study is a named group of analyses, for example Tail sizing.

  • To make one, select New study in the study bar above the projects, type a name and select Create.

  • To add analyses, tick them and select Add to study… ‣ New study… or the study’s name. In the dialog, type the name and select Create and add …. If a study of that name exists, the button reads Add to … and the analyses join it.

  • To take an analysis out, open the study, tick it and select Take out of ….

  • To remove a study, open it and select Remove study. Its analyses stay in your account. Keep it cancels.

A new study is kept in this browser until an analysis joins it; from then on it is kept with your account.

The study table

Select a study in the study bar, or Table above the projects, to see the analyses as a table with their values at fixed points: CL max, Stall angle, Best L/D, CD at CL (a CL you can change), Cm slope, and their Status, Note and Mark. Select a column heading to sort, and again to reverse. The status filter above the table shows, for example, only the failed or the warm-started analyses.

Select ☆ in the Mark column to mark one analysis ★ Baseline or ★ Best. The others then show their difference from it; grey ones are within the noise of the solution.

Versions and notes

The strip under a project’s title links its versions and notes:

  • Change and run again makes a new draft from the project, named for example Raven (2), with this project as its previous version. It opens on the Flight step; change what you want and launch. It keeps the studies, and not the notes or marks.

  • Version 2 · after … names the previous version. Compare with the previous version opens both on the Compare page.

  • Add to a study and the study chips, and Note for a note on the project.

To set the previous version by hand, open Project settings. Under Previous version, choose a project, or None: the first version.

In the Runs tab, the Note column holds a note on each run.